Evaluation Criteria for CIC R&D Programs

Relevance/Contribution
The research must significantly contribute to the overall goals of the Federal Computing, Information, and Communications (CIC) R&D programs, which include the goals of the five Program Component Areas Ð High End Computing and Computation, Large Scale Networking, High Confidence Systems, Human centered Systems, and Education, Training, and Human Resources Ð to enable solution of Grand Challenge- and National Challenge-class applications problems.

Technical/Scientific Merit
The proposed agency program must be technically/scientifically sound and of high quality and must be the product of a documented technical/scientific planning and review process.

Readiness
A clear agency planning process must be evident, and the organization must have demonstrated capability to carry out the program.

Timeliness
The proposed work must be technically/scientifically timely for one or more of the CIC R&D Program Component Areas.

Linkages
The responsible organization must have established policies, programs, and activities promoting effective technical and scientific connections among government, industry, and academic sectors.

Costs
The identified resources must be adequate, represent an appropriate share of the total available CIC R&D resources (e.g., a balance among Program Component Areas), promote prospects for joint funding, and address long term resource implications.

Agency Approval
The proposed program or activity must have policy-level approval by the submitting agency.